w0rp zone


A Year of ALE

It's been a little over a year now since I started working on what is arguably my first ever successful open source project, ALE. It's very ironic that I've been working on ALE for over a year, given that I've been teetotal my entire life. (This is actually mentioned way at the end of the help file, for those who bother to read it.) Some friends had told me that I should write up my experience with working on ALE so far. True to my fashion of being very lazy and proactive at the same time, I'm now ready to produce this article two months later.

When reading this article, it will be helpful if you are familiar with Vim scripting jargon. If you aren't as familiar with Vim, you can gloss over any strange words you see.


The first question to answer with this project is, "why did I bother working on it in the first place?" I alluded to my laziness above. Laziness is one of Larry Wall's three virtues. I wanted a tool which would check my code very well, so I could make fewer mistakes while working. Pointing out mistakes and letting me fix them as quickly as possible means I spend less time trying to fix simple mistakes, and I can focus more on the big picture.

Perhaps another virtue which could be added to Larry's list is jealousy. I was working with other programmers who could run flake8 in PyCharm or ESLint in Sublime or Atom, and they would receive information about problems in their code while they typed. My text editor of choice is Vim. Vim is the tool that allows me to edit code faster than any other tool. When I started working on ALE, Syntastic was the most popular Vim plugin for checking for problems. Syntastic and Vim at the time didn't allow you to check for errors while you type.

The reason why Vim plugins couldn't support checking for errors while you type is that checking for errors while you type requires support for asynchronous programming. Vim only allowed you to execute external programmings synchronously. Thus, Syntastic could only check for errors when files were opened or saved. Worse than that, checking for errors was a blocking operation, so you couldn't use your text editor at all while it was checking your code. One of the main reasons the NeoVim project was started was to introduce support for asynchronous programming in a fork of Vim. Meanwhile, when I started working on ALE, Vim 8 was being developed, which would introduce asynchronous programming support into Vim itself.

I really badly wanted to have the ability to check for problems while I typed in Vim, and I kept thinking about how that functionality could be introduced. After some thinking, I came up with a basic plan which could actually work.


I determined that linting while you type in Vim would require the following process.

  1. Start a timer function when text is changed, and cancel the timer if the timer is triggered again before the delay is hit. (This is a common pattern in client-side programming.)
  2. When the timer function is run, start some programs in the background to check for problems.
  3. After the programs finish, display the problems in the editor in various ways supported by Syntastic and other plugins.

I determined that such a plugin would have to be written from scratch, and that it actually wouldn't be that difficult to get something pretty basic working. I could get the bare minimum amount of code working in NeoVim, and then add in support for Vim 8 after that. With some free time on my hands and the drive to get something done, I got started.

After some tinkering, I managed to get asynchronous linting while you type to work in NeoVim and in a development version of Vim 8. I implemented basic loclist support and support for signs with Vim and NeoVim. I named the project "ALE" for "Asynchronous Lint Engine", because I have a fetish for catchy acronyms. I threw the project up on GitHub and uploaded it to the vim scripts site. I worded my project descriptions according to the SEO knowledge I have, so people could find the project easily via a Google search like "lint while typing vim." I announced the project in a response to Vim 8.0 release thread.

Early on I came up with a set of principles for the project, which I still adhere to.

  1. The code in the project needs to be covered with a good quality test suite.
  2. The project needs to support Linux, Mac OSX, and Windows.
  3. The project needs to support Vim 8 and somewhat recent versions of NeoVim.
  4. Just about everything should be documented.
  5. The project needs to be written almost entirely in VimL. Writing the project purely in VimL makes it portable.
  6. Linters should check for problems while you type, except when linters just work a lot better when they check the files on disk.
  7. ALE should try and check files with as many tools as possible by default, except where they are too annoying.
  8. ALE should prefer locally installed executables by default.

Before long, other users started opening issues on GitHub. More core functionality already implemented in Syntastic needed to be implemented. There were various bugs to fix. There were issues with cross-platform support to solve. New linters were being contributed by other users. Support for tools which just couldn't be run while you type was needed. The project started moving along at a decent pace.

Explosive Growth

As time has gone on, I and a few others have contributed some improvements to core functionality. A huge number of contributors have come along to contribute code for running linters for the languages they work with. My contributions to ALE are now mostly focused on improving the core functionality. I maintain the test suite and code quality, while anyone on the Internet can come along and submit pull requests for adding or improving support for other tools. I can think of no better way to illustrate the contributions to ALE than through gource.

I've seen ALE rise in popularity. The GitHub stars have risen from tens, to hundreds, to about 3,300 at the time this article was written. The number of contributors has risen. Articles have been written about ALE. ALE is going to be mentioned in an upcoming book called Modern Vim (I have reviewed the linting section myself.) ALE is mentioned in YouTube videos in foreign languages. When the last version of Ubuntu was released, around a thousand users cloned the repository in a day. ALE has become the de facto way to check for problems with your code in Vim.

I could probably write a very long article about my experiences in interacting with other human beings while supporting an open source project. Some people can be very mean. Some people don't speak English so well. Some users create issues which are very confusing indeed. Still, most people who comment are very polite. Many people open very valid issues with all of the information required. Many people contribute code to the project. I might write an article about working with humans in future.

A Growing Feature Set

As time has gone on, I've made a number of decisions for extending ALE's feature set. Sometimes the features seem like they might belong in another plugin, but I've had a good sense for figuring out which things matter so much that they should be supported by ALE. In no particular order, ALE has been extended with...

  • Various ways for displaying problems, including multi-line highlights.
  • Support for summaries in statuslines and various statusline plugins.
  • The documentation has been expanded greatly and revised many times.
  • The :ALEDetail command for showing more detailed messages for problems that are found.
  • The :ALEInfo command for showing detailed information for debugging problems with ALE. (This feature has massively improved the speed at which bugs are fixed and ALE is developed.)
  • Buffer-local versions of just about any setting, making it easier to configure different projects.
  • Support for applying settings based on regular expression matches for filenames.
  • Functions for loading tools from node_modules, virtualenv, and similar tools much more easily.
  • Support for fixing problems in code. (This feature has been very popular.)
  • Support for integrating with Language Server Protocol servers, and [tsserver](https://github.com/Microsoft/TypeScript/wiki/Standalone-Server-(tsserver) for TypeScript, which is similar.
  • Completion support for tsserver. (Support for general LSP servers will be added eventually.)
  • Various commands for controlling ALE.
  • All tests now pass in Windows on AppVeyor.
  • Too many smaller features to name!

In Closing

I'm happy I've been able to create something useful that a lot of people enjoy. The thanks for the project don't belong to me, but to everyone who has contributed. I would like to thank Mark Grealish especially for making ALE's cool logo based on my terrible crude drawing.

If you use Vim and you haven't tried ALE yet, go ahead and give it a try! I don't think it's a stretch to say that it generally does its job pretty damn well.

Post Your Comment

Need help with comment formatting?

Okay, here's a cheat sheet for you. Click here to get rid of this.

Choose a help topic below. Raw HTML for basic formatting allowed, and other HTML will be escaped. Other Markdown syntax is valid, but probably not relevant.

*italic* **bold**
_italic_ __bold__
1. Item #1
2. Item #2

* Unordered list item
* Unordered list item
Three backticks are your friend here: ```square = lambda x: x * x```

Also in a block like so:

def square(x):
  return x * x


Thanks for taking the time to share your experiences... this kind of retrospective on something they has blossomed will surely help open source as a whole and encourage more people to innovate and share.

I've been using ALE after refactoring my configs earlier this year and i must say it's very well laid out and it has improved my productivity massively..

Thank you!

ALE is very cool!

The word you want is envy, not jealousy. Jealousy is when you fear someone taking something that you have. Envy is when you want something that someone else has.

I determined that such a plugin would have to be written from scratch

How? Could Syntastic be improved instead? If no, why not?

More core functionality already implemented in Syntastic needed to be implemented

So did Syntastic catch up with ALE?

I could probably write a very long article about my experiences in interacting with other human beings

Please do! Looking forward to reading it!

The trouble with improving Syntastic was that a complete rewrite was needed for the functionality ALE now supports to work properly. Asynchronous programming requires a whole new way of thinking and rewriting pretty much everything. makeprg-style support in Syntastic needed to be replaced with callbacks and custom error handling. Starting fresh was the only way forward. ALE has essentially replaced Syntastic now.

ALEInfo is a great feature. More tools should have something like that. I absentmindedly clicked on this article while ALE was broken and it pointed me to reading that, which then indicated I should check if flake8 was installed.

ALE is a great plugin, thank you!

I love what you have done with ALE.

It has tremendously improved and definitely sped-up my life ;)

Thank you so much!

(At first I wanted to be constructive, but really I can only say how much I like it)